Greece violates legal obligations regarding Turkish minority rights
The Greek (L), Turkish (C) and European Union flags wave on the Greek Foreign Ministry house before a meeting of Foreign Minister Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu and his Greek counterpart Nikos Dendias in Athens, Greece, May 31, 2021. (AP File Photo)


Greece's Turkish minority has been experiencing numerous problems as a result of Athens' systematic policies, which aim to assimilate them in violation of the country's bilateral and international legal obligations. Arguably, the area of education is where this state of affairs is most obvious.

Currently, Greece's 150,000-strong Turkish minority, which is generally concentrated in the country's Western Thrace region, is being targetted and turned into second-class citizens in a region where they have lived for over six centuries.

The Treaty of Athens, signed in 1913 between the then-Ottoman Empire and the Kingdom of Greece, is the first essential legal assurance that addressed the education of the Turkish Muslim minority in Western Thrace. Protocol 3, Article 15 of the treaty protocol recognized the minority's right to education in the Turkish language.

Article 40 of the 1923 Treaty of Lausanne affirmed that the minority is entitled to open and operate minority schools in which education is offered in Turkish. Moreover, Articles 9 and 41 of the same treaty say the Greek state must facilitate the minority's education in its own language (Turkish), with the required funding allocated from local state authorities and administrations.

Furthermore, Greece, in 1954, in decree 3065, recognized the minority schools in Western Thrace as "Turkish schools" and allowed the opening of more such schools, including Celal Bayar Middle and High School in Gümülcine (Komotini).

However, seeing its Turkish Muslim minority as a "hostage" to ties with Turkey, Greece started to violate the minority's right to education in defiance of its own international legal obligations from the early 1960s onward. With the far-right Greek military junta of 1967, the oppression of the minority became more obvious and heavier. Through decree 1109 in 1972, the junta decided not to use "Turkish" to denote the minority in a motion rejecting the Turkishness of the Turkish Muslim minority in Western Thrace.

Even though the junta was toppled in 1974, its mistreatment of the Turkish minority was taken over and continued by successive democratically elected Greek governments. As such, through decrees 694 and 695 in 1977, Greece made the employment of teachers educated in Turkey practically impossible. It also disempowered the minority school committee in the hiring of teachers.

As if all these undermining efforts were not enough, Greece kept the duration of compulsory education six years for the minority schools as opposed to nine years for the rest of the country.

Considering that the minority in Western Thrace are Greek citizens who pay taxes and do obligatory military service, among their other obligations, this is a clear example of how Greece sees and treats them.

As an inevitable consequence, the number of Turkish minority schools has fallen from 231 in 1995 to fewer than 100 now. Similarly, the number of students attending these schools has drastically decreased.

What is more, Greece does not recognize the right to education in the Turkish language to around 5,000 members of the Turkish minority living on the islands of Kos and Rhodes, claiming they were not included in the Treaty of Lausanne.

Greece systematically defies its international and bilateral obligations towards the Turkish Muslim minority in Western Thrace and treats them as "second-class citizens or internal threats" instead of equal citizens, as the EU and the West opt to turn a blind eye.

Most recently, the Greek decision to close four more primary schools belonging to the Turkish Muslim minority in Western Thrace for the 2022-2023 school year has been decried by locals, calling the move part of a systematic plan to cut the number of minority schools.

The Treaty of Lausanne envisages educational autonomy for the Turkish community in Western Thrace, and minority schools are mandated to provide bilingual education in both Turkish and Greek. But over the last 27 years, the number of minority primary schools in the region has fallen sharply, from 231 to 99.

Only two schools, one in İskeçe (Xanthi) and the other in Komotini, provide secondary and high school education.

Turkey has called the Greek decision to close the schools "discrimination."

Foreign Minister Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu on Wednesday also slammed Athens on minority rights. He complained that Athens acts contrary to international law and violates basic human rights. Due to its flouting of the rights of Greece's Turkish Muslim minority, it has no say on the issue of human rights, he said.

Ankara has long decried Athens' violations of the rights of its Muslim and Turkish minority, from closing down mosques and shutting down schools, to banning associations with the word "Turkish" in the name, to not letting Muslim Turks elect their own religious leaders.

These measures violate the 1923 Treaty of Lausanne as well as European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) rulings, making Greece a state that flouts the law, say Turkish officials.