From artistic expression to divine unity: Beauty, order, existence
The Tillya-Kori, Ulugh Beg and Sher-Dor madrasas stand in Registan Square, Samarkand, Uzbekistan, Oct. 18, 2021. (Shutterstock Photo)

From the patterns of a painted surface to the intricate order of nature, beauty invites us to look beyond what the eye can see



A work of art begins long before the artist touches a brush, shapes a material or composes a sound. It begins with a world already rich in possibilities: light that reveals color, matter that can take shape, proportions that give composition meaning and relationships through which separate elements come together as a meaningful whole.

The artist works within this world, discovering its possibilities and transforming them into artistic expression.

This distinction raises a question that extends beyond aesthetics: if human creativity draws upon an order it cannot create, what does this tell us about the nature of existence itself?

Art of exchange

Throughout art history, originality has rarely been the product of isolation. Artistic languages have traveled across geographical and cultural boundaries, acquiring new meanings as they entered different intellectual worlds.

16th-century Iznik ceramics provide a compelling example. Chinese blue-and-white porcelain was admired at the Ottoman court, influencing the work of local artisans. Rather than reproducing these designs, Ottoman craftsmen reinterpreted elements of Chinese aesthetics within their own visual tradition, developing a distinctive palette of turquoise and tomato-red hues, complemented by floral motifs including tulips, carnations, hyacinths and roses.

What emerged was neither a replica of Chinese art nor an entirely separate invention, but a distinctive artistic expression born out of cultural exchange.

A similar exchange occurred in 19th-century Europe through Japanese ukiyo-e prints. Their asymmetrical compositions, unconventional perspectives, abrupt cropping and vivid colors offered European artists new possibilities for representing the visible world. Edgar Degas explored different approaches to movement and composition; Mary Cassatt reinterpreted Japanese visual arrangements in her color etchings; Vincent van Gogh studied and transformed the prints of Hiroshige.

These encounters did not erase artistic identities; they expanded them.

The distinction between imitation and genuine creativity lies in the ability to recognize possibilities within another tradition and transform them without reducing them to one's own familiar conventions.

Yet these encounters point to a deeper question: if artistic traditions draw upon possibilities that precede them, what does this tell us about the nature of the order underlying existence?

Order within

An artistic tradition is shaped by more than technique. It reflects a particular way of understanding proportion, symmetry, nature, movement, space and the relationship between the individual and the whole.

Islamic geometric art makes this relationship particularly visible. Its intricate patterns bring repetition, symmetry and interconnectedness into harmony, allowing individual elements to form part of a greater whole. Despite their apparent multiplicity, the patterns convey a remarkable sense of unity.

This relationship between diversity and order is not exclusive to art. It is also encountered in the natural world, where different structures participate in intricate systems of correspondence and interdependence.

Consider a flower. Its beauty lies not only in its colors but also in the intricate relationships that shape its form, growth and interaction with the surrounding world. Science can explore the processes behind these relationships, just as the human eye can appreciate their beauty. Yet explaining how they function is not the same as accounting for their existence.

To recognize order is one thing; to account for its ultimate source is another.

This distinction is important because complexity alone does not account for coherence. Nor does understanding the laws governing nature necessarily explain why the world follows an intelligible order in the first place.

The question of existence, therefore, goes beyond describing how things function. It also invites us to consider what makes their existence possible.

Limits of human creation

Modern discussions of art often present the artist as an independent creator, celebrating originality, imagination and the ability to produce something entirely new. Yet even the most original work draws upon realities that exist independently of the artist.

Just as a painter does not determine the properties of light and color, a sculptor does not define the nature of stone, nor does a composer invent the principles that make musical harmony possible.

The artist discovers possibilities, recognizes relationships and gives them a particular expression.

This does not make human creativity any less remarkable. It simply places it in a different perspective.

There is a fundamental difference between bringing an existing possibility into a particular form and being the ultimate source of that possibility. However extraordinary its achievements, human creativity remains rooted in an order beyond its own making.

What, then, is the ultimate source of the realities that make human creativity possible?

For a believer, the source of this order is the One Creator, whose wisdom and power are reflected throughout creation. The countless forms of existence are not separate realities but diverse expressions of a greater unity. The world, in this understanding, is not merely something to be observed. It is something to be read.

Multiplicity, unity

The relationship between multiplicity and unity offers a profound way of understanding the nature of existence.

The language of Islamic thought provides a framework for contemplating this relationship: kesret (multiplicity) and vahdet (unity).

Kesret describes the abundance and diversity of created existence, while vahdet directs the intellect toward the unity of its ultimate source. These are not competing descriptions. Rather, the multiplicity of creation becomes an occasion for recognizing the unity of the Creator.

The same relationship can be contemplated through art. A composition brings together different colors, forms and elements, yet its coherence emerges from the relationships between them. The whole reveals something that no individual component can express on its own.

In this sense, the diversity of existence invites us to look beyond individual forms and consider the unity that gives them coherence.

Seeing responsibly

There is a difference between admiring what we see and understanding what its existence reveals. In a world saturated with images, the challenge is no longer simply to see more, but to understand more deeply. The act of reflection begins when admiration becomes inquiry, leading us beyond appearances toward questions of source and meaning.

Artistic forms circulate across cultures at unprecedented speed. Yet when their historical and intellectual foundations are removed, cultural differences risk being reduced to appearances. Traditions become collections of recognizable motifs, and cultural exchange risks becoming the consumption of visual identities.

A civilization preserves its artistic inheritance not by refusing encounters, but by understanding what gives its forms meaning. Genuine exchange requires knowledge, intellectual humility and respect for the histories behind different artistic traditions.

The individual, too, must approach beauty with a willingness to look beyond its immediate appeal and consider the questions it raises about form, order, existence and meaning.

Perhaps the deepest failure of modern perception is not that beauty has disappeared, but that we have become accustomed to encountering it without asking what it reveals.

To see more deeply is to ask not only what makes something beautiful, but what makes beauty possible in the first place.