The question of whether developing countries will be more fragile and experience new financial crises after the U.S. Federal Reserve's (Fed) interest rate hike completely depends on the monetary and fiscal policies that these countries will pursue going forward. The central banks of developed countries, particularly the Fed, have kept interest rates near zero and have pushed up money supply for nearly seven years. However, the Fed's interest rate increase does not indicate that this aggressive standpoint of the central banks of developed countries has absolutely ended. Particularly, the European Central Bank (ECB) has to maintain its expansionist monetary policies. Also, the Bank of England and the Bank of Japan have to find more effective policies apart from their traditional expansionist policies. If these banks incline toward tight, orthodox monetary policies - which are the complete opposite of the policies that they have pursued up until now, thinking that they have fizzled out - the anti-inflationist process, which is the most important constructive dynamic of the current crisis, will intensify, and the world's output gap will increase. This signifies a never-ending crisis for everyone. So, developed countries have to seek a new path aside from their monetary expansion policies that cannot overcome the liquidity trap, and they have to even further intensify this trap in a paradoxical way. They need a new economic policy framework that will support leading sectors, drive up economic externalities and boost employment in these sectors. The whole of Europe should discuss a new and holistic economic policy that has a broadened social framework in order to bring Eastern and Southern European countries, particularly Greece, closer to Northern European countries. At this point, the EU should immediately bring up a new expansionist strategy that will cover Turkey as well. At the same time, this is the sole way to prevent the frozen conflict areas in the Middle East, the Caucasus and North Africa from becoming civil war areas, as well as overcome the refugee crisis. Note that in many parts of the world, including the Middle East, the dynamics of civil war emerge because of bad economic policies that primarily serve the interests of global financial capital. We should start discussing new monetary and financial policies that will highlight inclusive growth and improve income distribution around the world.
On the other hand, central banks and governments in developing countries should abandon neoliberal monetary and fiscal policies. These central banks have to change their monetary policies, which merely focus on ensuring financial stability and lowering inflation. Also, their monetary policies must go beyond the contractionary understanding that is based on having non-interest surplus and bears the risk of recession. For instance, all central banks, including the Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey (CBRT), must control money supply and support the market with money supply if needed. In addition to its nominal value, the real value of money supply is important, and it is even more critical in terms of its economic activity level. A central bank that fails to supervise its own money cannot determine interest rates, which is the price of money. The monetary policy framework that is called inflation targeting can determine interest rates; however, it cannot control the monetary base. Since the 2001 crisis, the CBRT initially pursued an implicit inflation-targeting model and then switched to an open inflation targeting practice.
Generally speaking, as new classical economists argue, inflation targeting is a policy strategy that is based on the argument that perfect efficiency is taken for granted in pure competition markets and asset markets. It also argues that the general administration of the economy can be realized only by directing interest rates in open economic conditions. The policy rates, which are the main instrument of inflation targeting, theoretically give a central bank the opportunity to determine a monetary base in an indirect way by steering the interbank money market. Another result obtained from inflation targeting is to determine credit interests by the indirect means of policy interest rates.
The essential point here is the situation where banks' demand for money is stable. In this case, central banks will both make the monetary base stable and steer the economy by controlling interest rates. If monetary base demand is not stable, current policies will make interest rates relatively stable. This is only possible with the achievement of a competitive banking sector. If monetary base demand is unstable and the banking sectors face the lack of competition, real credit interests will gain stability at very excessive levels. If a central bank does not determine interest rates as a policy instrument and leaves it to markets, it can ensure monetary control in a sounder way. If monetary base demand is stable, interest fluctuations will be on an ignorable level and monetary control will be stronger. However, if monetary base demand is unstable, interest rates will be volatile, but the central bank will have a high control over monetary indicators.
Interest targeting, which is the basic instrument of an inflation-targeting regime, in countries where real monetary supply shrinks and is highly unstable, will minimize the monetary control of the central bank. In developing countries like Turkey, money supply is unstable and the banking system has an oligopolistic structure. Actually, this situation is a reality of the global economy. Inflation targeting produces relatively positive results in high-income group countries where the development level differences between regions are low and the need for development is at the minimum level. On the contrary, in addition to creating problems about growth and distribution in the real economy in countries like Turkey where there is need for development and rapid growth and differences in development levels between regions is high, it removes the central bank's control over its own money supply.
In short, inflation targeting, which is one of the most important topics of neoliberal monetary policy, which is imposed on developing countries, highlights an oligopolistic and crippled market, and rules out a floating exchange rate regime practice. As can be seen, both developed and developing countries should abandon these outdated practices, which are scientifically falsified now, and switch to new monetary and fiscal policies that highlight inclusive growth and fair income distribution.
About the author
NULL
The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author. They do not necessarily reflect the editorial stance, values or position of Daily Sabah. The newspaper provides space for diverse perspectives as part of its commitment to open and informed public discussion.
Keep up to date with what’s happening in Turkey,
it’s region and the world.
You can unsubscribe at any time. By signing up you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.