It might be more merciful to shoot kangaroos rather than let them starve to death, ecologists suggested as they warned that Australia's iconic species could die in "catastrophic" numbers if a population boom is left unchecked, backing the industrial-scale culling of the marsupials.
To outsiders, the kangaroo is an instantly recognizable symbol of the Australian wilderness, but within the country, the native animal poses a major environmental headache.
Kangaroos have a "boom and bust" population cycle – when fodder is plentiful on the back of a good wet season their numbers can balloon by tens of millions.
Hopping mobs of kangaroos can rapidly strip paddocks bare, but ecologist Katherine Moseby warned they would starve to death in droves when food ran out.
"The last drought we estimated that 80 or 90% of the kangaroos in some areas died," she told Agence France-Presse (AFP).
"They are starving to death – going into public toilets and eating toilet paper, or lying on the road starving while their joeys are trying to feed," she added, referring to events from the last population boom.
Moseby said the kindest way to save kangaroos from this fate was to shoot them and harvest the meat, as a way of keeping numbers in check.
"It keeps the numbers down so that when we do get drought we don't get these welfare issues," she said.
"If we saw them as a resource and managed them like that, we wouldn't get the catastrophic deaths that we see."
Kangaroos are protected in Australia but the most common species are not endangered – this means they can be shot and killed in most jurisdictions, but government permission is needed.
Each year, as many as five million kangaroos are shot as part of a homegrown industry, which harvests their carcasses for meat, pet food and leather.
Dennis King from the Kangaroo Industry Association of Australia believes the country is on the cusp of another kangaroo boom.
"After three years of La Nina right down the east coast, we've seen the perfect growth scenario for kangaroos over the next couple of years," he told AFP.
"The breeding cycle really speeds up."
King said the national kangaroo population fell under 30 million following a crippling drought in the early 2000s, but could soon rebound to as many as 60 million.
Animal rights activists have denounced the commercial cull as a "cruel slaughter," pressuring global sportswear giants such as Nike and Puma to phase out the use of kangaroo leather.
"Nike divested of its only kangaroo leather supplier in 2021 and will stop making any product with kangaroo leather in 2023," a spokeswoman for the company said in March.
Politicians in Oregon, where Nike was founded, introduced a bill earlier this year that would outlaw the use of "any part of a dead kangaroo."
"These native animals are slaughtered for the sake of commercial profit," Animals Australia said earlier this year.
George Wilson, a leading researcher on kangaroo management, said attempts to shut down the industry were well-intentioned but ultimately misguided.
"They say it's unethical, but it's unethical to let them starve to death," he told AFP.
"The cruelty is not doing anything about it."
Moseby agreed, saying ending the culling of kangaroos would actually be more cruel in the long run.
"Trying to stop the harvest of leather or meat, it's not going to have any welfare benefit," she said.
"It's going to make it worse."
