Daily Sabah logo

Politics
Diplomacy Legislation War On Terror EU Affairs Elections News Analysis
TÜRKİYE
Istanbul Education Investigations Minorities Expat Corner Diaspora
World
Mid-East Europe Americas Asia Pacific Africa Syrian Crisis Islamophobia
Business
Automotive Economy Energy Finance Tourism Tech Defense Transportation News Analysis
Lifestyle
Health Environment Travel Food Fashion Science Religion History Feature Expat Corner
Arts
Cinema Music Events Portrait Reviews Performing Arts
Sports
Football Basketball Motorsports Tennis
Opinion
Columns Op-Ed Reader's Corner Editorial
PHOTO GALLERY
JOBS ABOUT US RSS PRIVACY CONTACT US
© Turkuvaz Haberleşme ve Yayıncılık 2023

Daily Sabah logo

عربي
  • Politics
    • Diplomacy
    • Legislation
    • War On Terror
    • EU Affairs
    • Elections
    • News Analysis
  • TÜRKİYE
    • Istanbul
    • Education
    • Investigations
    • Minorities
    • Expat Corner
    • Diaspora
  • World
    • Mid-East
    • Europe
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Africa
    • Syrian Crisis
    • Islamophobia
  • Business
    • Automotive
    • Economy
    • Energy
    • Finance
    • Tourism
    • Tech
    • Defense
    • Transportation
    • News Analysis
  • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Environment
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Fashion
    • Science
    • Religion
    • History
    • Feature
    • Expat Corner
  • Arts
    • Cinema
    • Music
    • Events
    • Portrait
    • Reviews
    • Performing Arts
  • Sports
    • Football
    • Basketball
    • Motorsports
    • Tennis
  • Gallery
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Op-Ed
    • Reader's Corner
    • Editorial
  • TV
  • Opinion
  • Columns
  • Op-Ed
  • Reader's Corner
  • Editorial

Challenges for Turkey’s South Asia relations after Afghanistan 

by Omair Anas

Sep 16, 2021 - 12:05 am GMT+3
Taliban forces patrol in front of Hamid Karzai International Airport in Kabul, Afghanistan, Sept. 2, 2021. (REUTERS Photo)
Taliban forces patrol in front of Hamid Karzai International Airport in Kabul, Afghanistan, Sept. 2, 2021. (REUTERS Photo)
by Omair Anas Sep 16, 2021 12:05 am

After the sudden Taliban takeover in Afghanistan, both Turkey and other international stakeholders need to update their South Asian policies

RECOMMENDED
The existence of God was not proved or defended instead his existence was accepted directly, and men interpreted the existence and the universe in the direction of this knowledge. (Illustration by Erhan Yalvaç)

The existence of God: Is it possible to prove?

Faith

The dramatic events in Afghanistan have changed many long-standing rules when it comes to regional security in South and Central Asia. The Taliban’s take over of Afghanistan – without a negotiated transition as was planned by the Qatari-mediated Taliban-U.S. negotiations – has stalled many countries’ preparations for the post-U.S. withdrawal.

Turkey was among the key countries actively engaged in the post-U.S. invasion transition, development and inclusive governance of Afghanistan. The Heart of Asia, or the Istanbul Process in its initial format, aimed to establish a regional consensus to assure a peaceful, stable and sustainable future for Afghanistan.

After the U.S.-Taliban dialogues were opened in Doha, Turkey was also informed that the U.S. withdrawal was imminent. However, it may not have made the necessary calculations for an abrupt, unplanned, almost chaotic withdrawal. Not just Turkey, most NATO allies were not given enough room to prepare for a graceful transition. It does not mean though that Turkey was unprepared for the Taliban's takeover.

U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo speaks as Zalmay Khalilzad, U.S. envoy for peace in Afghanistan, Qatari Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani and Mutlaq bin Majed al-Qahtani, special envoy of the foreign minister of Qatar are seen during talks between the Afghan government and Taliban insurgents in Doha, Qatar Sept.12, 2020. (REUTERS Photo)
U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo speaks as Zalmay Khalilzad, U.S. envoy for peace in Afghanistan, Qatari Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani and Mutlaq bin Majed al-Qahtani, special envoy of the foreign minister of Qatar are seen during talks between the Afghan government and Taliban insurgents in Doha, Qatar Sept.12, 2020. (REUTERS Photo)

Turkey's relations with South Asia

However, as per the Doha-mediated dialogues, the withdrawal should have been accompanied by a smooth transition and a negotiated transfer of power to provide necessary assurances to the people of Afghanistan about the security of their future. The scenes of panicked exodus at the Kabul Hamid Karzai International Airport in the last week of August were enough to prove that the American withdrawal was unprepared and unplanned. The consequences of the U.S. failure in Afghanistan are now being felt in other countries where thousands of Afghan refugees are now heading.

For Turkey, such an abrupt change of power has it questioning its South Asia policy. There are many avoidable things that Turkey has been left to deal with both alone and in cooperation with other countries. As a result, Turkey is forced to review its South Asia policy and adjust to the changing prospects.

Historically, Turkey has been eager to maintain connectivity and influence on both sides of its eastern and western borders. While the western borders define Turkey’s security and strategic interests, the eastern borders define Turkey’s transcontinental spiritual, cultural and linguistic affinities. From the 16th century onwards, Turkey carefully balanced between the Mughal, Safavid and Uzbek Khanate’s triangle of competition and cooperation. With the British colonization of South Asia, Afghanistan became a hotbed of rivalry between the British and Russian imperial ambitions.

The Ottoman Empire had to keep the Russians from reaching Indian borders at the request of British India. When the Indian freedom movement spread globally, Raja Mahendra Pratap Singh secured active Turkish support in establishing an Indian government in exile in Kabul in 1915. However, with India’s independence, the region completely changed, leaving it partitioned into two nation-states and then divided into two opposite international camps.

While Turkey had succeeded in deepening its military and cultural ties with Pakistan and Afghanistan, it lost its influence in most of Soviet Central Asia and in non-aligned countries, including India. A staunchly secular Turkey had lost interest in Afghanistan’s anti-Soviet mujahideen, or holy warriors, who would later be embroiled in an unending violent power struggle among themselves. Even in the U.S. war on terror in the aftermath of the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, Turkey was sensitive enough to become part of the U.S-led NATO operation in Afghanistan, choosing to restrict its participation to only non-combatant roles. Meanwhile, Turkey kept struggling to revive its role in Afghanistan by supporting political process and development projects, with minimum outcomes nevertheless.

Now, with the Taliban in full control of Kabul, Afghanistan's relations with Pakistan, India, Central Asia, Iran and the Gulf, as well as the strategic value it places on them, will be tested. The Taliban are aware of Turkey’s growing economic and security profile in regional and international politics, and at some point in time, the Taliban will need Turkey’s help. Turkey has, however, many reasons to worry about the future of Afghanistan and the future of Turkey’s South and Central Asia policy.

Taliban fighters patrol a market in Kabul, Afghanistan, Sept. 14, 2021. (AP Photo)
Taliban fighters patrol a market in Kabul, Afghanistan, Sept. 14, 2021. (AP Photo)

What should be done?

Turkey shouldn't mind if the Taliban change their identity from a violent religious outfit to a nationalist political movement. The earlier version of the Taliban had a declared association with al-Qaida and Osama bin Laden, and ambitions beyond Afghanistan – similar to the Iranian revolution of 1979 that aimed to export the uprising to all Islamic countries.

Turkey today also claims to be a leading example of moderate Islam, where politics are not dictated by sectarian, ethnic or religious differences. Unfortunately, Afghanistan has been mired in a spiral of ethnic, sectarian and religious conflicts. Scores of deaths and violence have been justified by these mere reasons. Also, Central Asian countries where religion and politics have been kept separate will be wary of Afghan spillover in their domestic politics. Therefore, it is in Turkey’s interest to encourage the Taliban to come out from the shadow of the past and offer inclusive politics.

Another problem is that almost all Afghan warring factions have a foreign backer. Allowing Afghanistan to be used by these countries will have destabilizing effects for the region. The bilateral conflicts between Pakistan-Iran, India-Pakistan and Iran-Saudi Arabia, for example, should not be settled on Afghan soil. The Taliban have reached out to India and Iran to assure them that Afghan territories will not be used for anti-Iran or anti-India activities. Such assurances from the Taliban, if maintained, are also going to help Turkey.

The biggest challenge that Turkey has been facing in its South Asia policy is how to balance very unpredictable India-Pakistan relations. When Afghanistan formally became a member of the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) in 2007, Afghanistan had the opportunity to integrate with the region economically, culturally and diplomatically. The Taliban need to acknowledge the importance of regional cooperation if they want to save Afghanistan from descending into chaos and instability.

At the same time, Afghanistan needs to maintain diversified diplomatic, strategic and economic relations without becoming dependent on a single country. For example, China’s Belt and Road Initiative is an opportunity for Afghanistan but the country has yet to find a way to utilize this road for two-way trade.

Afghanistan needs countries like Turkey, India and other growing economies to repair and rebuild a truly sustainable post-war economy. Convincing the Taliban that economic reforms are needed and establishing the necessary political and security environment will be the most important tasks Turkey will undertake if it aims to follow a revitalized South Asia policy.

About the author
PhD in Middle East Studies from the School of International Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi
RECOMMENDED
The existence of God was not proved or defended instead his existence was accepted directly, and men interpreted the existence and the universe in the direction of this knowledge. (Illustration by Erhan Yalvaç)

The existence of God: Is it possible to prove?

Faith
  • shortlink copied
  • RELATED TOPICS
    fight-against-terrorism DEUTSCHE-BANK US-LIBYA-RELATIONS
    KEYWORDS
    taliban us invasion turkey-afghanistan relations
    The Daily Sabah Newsletter
    Keep up to date with what’s happening in Turkey, it’s region and the world.
    You can unsubscribe at any time. By signing up you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
    President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and Swedish Prime Minister Ulf Kristersson (L) hold a press conference following their meeting at the Presidential Palace in the capital Ankara, Türkiye, Nov. 8, 2022. (AFP File Photo)

    Türkiye-Sweden row hints at deeper concerns within NATO

    türkiye-sweden-relations
    Greek naval forces conducted routine patrol missions around the Mediterranean island of Kastellorizo, one of the easternmost islands in Greece, which is just 3 kilometers (1.8 miles) from the southern coast of Kaş, Türkiye, Dec. 30, 2022. (Reuters Photo)

    Türkiye will not stand by as Greece threatens security: Erdoğan

    türkiye-greece-relations

    Norway cancels Quran burning after reaction from Türkiye

    QURAN-BURNING

    Türkiye summons envoys of 9 countries to express dismay over closure

    TURKIYE-EUROPE-RELATIONS
    Cappadocia, Nevşehir
    Pitch a tent at these stunning campsites in Turkey this fall
    PHOTOGALLERY
    • POLITICS
    • Diplomacy
    • Legislation
    • War On Terror
    • EU Affairs
    • News Analysis
    • TÜRKİYE
    • Istanbul
    • Education
    • Investigations
    • Minorities
    • Diaspora
    • World
    • Mid-East
    • Europe
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Africa
    • Syrian Crisis
    • İslamophobia
    • Business
    • Automotive
    • Economy
    • Energy
    • Finance
    • Tourism
    • Tech
    • Defense
    • Transportation
    • News Analysis
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Environment
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Fashion
    • Science
    • Religion
    • History
    • Feature
    • Expat Corner
    • Arts
    • Cinema
    • Music
    • Events
    • Portrait
    • Performing Arts
    • Reviews
    • Sports
    • Football
    • Basketball
    • Motorsports
    • Tennis
    • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Op-Ed
    • Reader's Corner
    • Editorial
    • Photo gallery
    • Jobs
    • privacy
    • about us
    • contact us
    • RSS
    © Turkuvaz Haberleşme ve Yayıncılık 2021